I got a question for you.
On 10/6/25
you said:
from the Perseverance Rover Camera
Avi Loeb Medium 10/06/25
"The highest resolution image was taken by the HiRISE camera onboard the Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter. HiRISE has an angular resolution that translated to 30 kilometers per pixel on October 3, 2025. The brightest pixel in the HiRISE image will provide the best constraint yet on the area of 3I/ATLAS. We are all hoping that the HiRISE team will release their images as soon as possible."
(October 3rd was when 3I/ATLAS
was at its closest to mars.)
Previously On 10/15/25
you had said:
New Images of Nickel and Cyanide
Around 3I/ATLAS from the Keck Telescope
Avi Loeb Medium 10/15/25
"We are still waiting
for the public release
of the images taken
by the HiRISE camera
onboard the Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter
on October 2, 2025."
WHY THE DISCREPENCY
ALL THE SUDDEN?
Also,
on 09/01/25
you stated:
Avi Loeb Medium 9/01/25
"In addition, an orbit correction by 10–15 kilometers per second during the month of September 2025, could shrink the closest approach distance of 3I/ATLAS from Mars to ZERO, as calculated in Figure 4 of my paper with Adam Hibberd and Adam Crowl (accessible here).
So this thing gets hit with a Coronal Mass Ejection, and no new trajectories have been given since, all then all along till yesterday we were being being told:
"The highest resolution image was taken by the HiRISE camera onboard the Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter. HiRISE has an angular resolution that translated to 30 kilometers per pixel on October 3, 2025."
And now that has been changed to:
"We are still waiting
for the public release
of the images taken
by the HiRISE camera
onboard the Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter
on October 2, 2025."
So why not the
"image (that) was taken"
from Oct 3rd?
When it was as it's
closest?
You have been saying:
"The highest resolution image was taken by the HiRISE camera onboard the Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter. HiRISE has an angular resolution that translated to 30 kilometers per pixel on October 3, 2025."
for a while now.
So it's not like you just got the date wrong
all the sudden
or it is some technical time keeping error etc.
So to what
do you attribute the discrepancy?
Keep in mind Avi also stated:
Saturday, October 11, 2025
he is trying to say
it didn't have any effect on Mars orbit.
(It didn't "perturb" it)
It was to far away,
had to small
of a gravitational field."
Avi Loeb Medium 10/11/25
"All in all, despite its mass of more than 33 billion tons (as derived here), the gravity of 3I/ATLAS is rather weak. The gravitational kick it gave to Mars as it passed at a speed of 67 kilometers per second at a minimum separation of 29 million kilometers on October 3, 2025, was a part in 5 trillion...amounting to an unmeasurable velocity kick of 2x10^{-12} meters per second."
To which I replied:
"If it wasnt really a thing?
Then why even bring it up
right now?"
It's okay really...
don't worry about it
This community
already knows wats up.
No comments:
Post a Comment