Thursday, November 6, 2025

Apparently some people didn't get the memo...(3I/ATLAS)

 


No Clear Cometary Tail 

in Post-Perihelion Images of 3I/ATLAS

Avi Loeb Medium 11/05/25



Post-perihelion image of the interstellar object 3I/ATLAS, 

taken on November 5, 2025 

by the R. Naves Observatory, 

shows a fuzzy ball of light. 

(Remember when that picture was taken, Nov 5th)

The Sunward direction is towards the bottom left corner (with the arrow on the left pointing in the anti-Sun direction). No obvious cometary tail is seen. (Credit: R. Naves Observatory, Spain).


(Comets have tails, duh.)


"On November 5, 2025, 

two new images of the interstellar object 3I/ATLAS 

were released. 

They show a compact source of light without a clear cometary tail. The coma is not very different in morphology than its appearance in the Hubble Space Telescope on July 21, 2025.



Virtualtelescope


"This is surprising in view of NASA’s JPL report 

here of a non-gravitational acceleration..."


(Funny thing about things that shouldn't exist

to begin with

they don't have to play by our rules...


Tuesday, August 12, 2025

Two problems here...(3I/ATLAS) 

I said after reading the first article about it: 

"It's not a comet."


The Release of Dust from the Surface of 3I/ATLAS 

Does Not Imply That it is a Comet

Avi Loeb Medium 8/12/25


"The fundamental uncertainty about the new interstellar object 3I/ATLAS involves its size. 

With the typical albedo of 5% for an asteroid, 

its diameter needs to be 20 kilometers 

in order to account for its brightness. 

But as argued in my first paper about it, 

the reservoir of rocky material 

in interstellar space 

can only deliver a 20-kilometer rock 

once per 10,000 years, 

even in the unlikely case 

that all this interstellar material 

is packed in 20-kilometer rocks."


(Simply put:

It should not exist.)


AND:

Preliminary Anomalies of 3I/ATLAS

Avi Loeb Medium Jul 12, 2025)


"detecting a 20-kilometer asteroid 

in the inner solar system 

over the survey period of 5 years 

has a probability of 0.0001 

based on the total reservoir 

of interstellar asteroids."

(Thats a 1 in 10,000 chance BTW.


Now Back to Avis blog post:)


"Based on momentum conservation (as discussed here), I derived here that 

the mass fraction lost during the perihelion passage 

of 3I/ATLAS is larger than 13%. 

For a typical comet, this should have resulted in a massive coma with dust and gas that would have been pushed by the solar radiation pressure and the solar wind to the shape of a typical cometary tail pointing away from the Sun. 

No such tail is visible 

in the new images 

from November 5, 2025.


(And who is surprised really?

"Funny thing about things that shouldn't exist

to begin with

they don't have to play by our rules.")


"In comparison, I include below an image of the solar system’s comet Lemmon, taken by one of the telescopes that observed 3I/ATLAS two days ago. Lemmon features a clear cometary tail pointing away from the Sun, as expected."



(Thats what a comet should look like.)



And now this from SETI 

"SETI Institute is a non-profit research organization, located in the Silicon Valley close to the NASA Ames Research Center. Our mission is to 
lead humanity's quest to understand the origins 
and prevalence of life and intelligence 
in the universe 
and share that knowledge with the world.

SETI Institute began small, with just one project – NASA’s SETI program – and two employees, founder Tom Pierson (a former grants administrator at San Francisco State University), and astronomer Jill Tarter. Over the years, other research disciplines have been added to the Institute’s portfolio, all 
unified by their relevance to the search for, 
and understanding of, life beyond Earth. 
Today, the Institute has approximately 100 scientists as well as specialists in administration, education, and outreach."


From SETI
Monday, Nov 03, 2025


"Orbital Behavior and Non-Gravitational Forces

Currently, 3I/ATLAS lies behind the Sun as seen from Earth, making it temporarily invisible to ground-based telescopes.




Apparently the R. Naves Observatory, 

and the virtual telescope project 

(And others)

didn't get that memo

about it no being observable from earth.


Amateur astronomers with six inch telescopes 

who have the proper view and know where to look

have found 3I/ATLAS at twilight 

in the night sky as well.


Astronomer reveals first look at Comet 3I/ATLAS 

as it reappears from behind the sun

Live science 11/03/25


"Qicheng Zhang, a postdoctoral fellow at the observatory, has subsequently found that the comet is also visible using small telescopes, 

posting an example of this to his Cometary blog 

on Sunday (Nov. 2). 

According to Zhang, standard amateur telescopes should now start picking up the comet across much of the Northern Hemisphere."


When all of this started

we were told it wouldn't be visible again until 

early December.


Thursday, October 2, 2025

I wouldn't be expecting much (3I/ATLAS)


These robots on Mars 

are about to get our closest view yet 

of the mysterious interstellar visitor

BBC Sky at night magazine.  10/01/25


"3I/ATLAS about to disappear behind the Sun from our perspective on Earth, and 

won't be visible again 

until early December 2025

when it emerges into our sky again.""

Frustratingly, this period marks the point 

at which it will be most active."


Tuesday, October 21, 2025

NASA transparency (3I/ATLAS)


Harvard professor issues warning about 3I/ATLAS 

that may affect your vacation plans 

& claims NASA is keeping secrets


"Gonna be interesting 

here come 

early December

when this thing

gets in view

of earth bound telescopes."

Yup...


Almost like 

they didn't want people looking for it 

in the night sky right now...

(Early November)

Hum...interesting)


"Its orbit – a hyperbolic path that ensures it will not return to our Solar System – takes it just inside the orbit of Mars. As it passes perihelion, astronomers track its motion using minor deviations from purely gravitational motion. 

These non-gravitational accelerations arise 

when jets of gas and dust escaping 

from the surface act like tiny thrusters, 

subtly altering the comet’s trajectory.


Such behavior is typical among active comets, 

reinforcing the importance of continuous monitoring. 

Through the Unistellar Network, 

a global community of citizen astronomers

 coordinated by the SETI Institute, 

scientists collect near-continuous photometric data, 

measuring changes in brightness 

that signal new outbursts 

OR FRAGMENTATION EVENTS.


Just before 3I/ATLAS became unobservable, Unistellar data showed an unexpected surge in brightness. 

This brightening exceeded predictions, 

hinting at either a sudden outburst of gas 

or an increase in surface activity. 

Space-based solar observatories 

later confirmed that 

the brightening 

persisted through perihelion, 

suggesting a significant change

 in the comet’s physical state."


Maybe that's why 

they didnt want people looking at it?


A lot of people

are flat out lying through their teeth

about this object

(3I/ATLAS)

and its becoming 

more and more obvious

just why that is.




No comments: